Papa Santos's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria

Good pizza deals, the pasta was too undercooked though.

HORRIBLE SERVICE!!! Asked for mushrooms in stromboli got onions, asked got extra mayo on sub got none, waitress had no idea what she was doing, appetizer platter was a huge disappointment.......waitress threw away rest of food without asking if we were done or wanted it to go...horrible...never again..don't waste your money here. Staff didn't care. Manager didn't care that his waitress messed up everything....I'd give them zero stars if possible

Excellent service, very friendly. Fast food, even faster workers. Service with a smile. I go out of my way just to come to this pizza restaurant!

Heros are pretty good. Service is pretty. Pizza is pretty good. Was my second time in

This place is amazing! The young lady we had was very attentive and sweet. We were visiting the area and didn't know their food specials so she walked us through everything on the menu. The food was excellent and the wings are GREAT! Didn't expect much because of location but this is truly a place you where "Never judge a book by it's cover" wins.

The food was delicious, reasonably priced, and the staff delightful. A very pleasant dining experience.

Food is usually good, but bread is consistently disappointing, they could be top notch if they just tried decent bread

Friendly service. We ordered take-out and everything was delicious. Big portions and reasonable pricing. Definitely can't wait to come back again.

I can't explain how good the pizza and sub was here!! We are 2 hours away from thos place, but will definitely drive again for their pizza and sub!! ❤

Great food, excellent pizza. Dinner specials and B.O. B. You have to give it a try you'll love the food

This cheesesteak with green bell peppers is one of the best I've ever had

Real Italian Pizza Restaurant, Great food, dinner specials are incredible money savers. Staff was great!

The stromboli and mozzarella sticks are great. The waitress was super nice -- great service.

Delicious! Everything from the appetizers to the dessert were amazing! So good! The sauces on the entrees were perfect and the prices were very fair. No complaints, we would definitely come back here. O and BYOB!

Great pizza ☺️ great service 👍

The pizza was good. If you are from the Poconos you know there is no good pizza. This place is definitely worth the pilgrimage to the other end of 940. I was very pleasantly surprised.

Absolutely love this place the food is great and the prices are reasonable if you visit the pocono this place is a must stop for dinner !!

Ordered a calzone with some extra toppings. The one I received didn't include the toppings. Garlic bread that was ordered never showed up. Shrimp and Scallop pasta was decent. For some reason, you can't order a pizza that was half hawaiian and half mushroom.

Great local Pizza Shop. Good tasting pizza, cooked it well done per our request. Will go there again if we are in the area.

First time dining here, visiting from Long Island. Had the Veal Parm dinner. It was really very good. Nice size portions. Prices are very reasonable. Casual pizzeria style atmosphere. Place was packed so that should say it all.

Delicious pizza! Extensive menu. Very clean restaurant with lots of seating. Extremely friendly staff. Good prices.

nice place..super friendly staff.. tried the stuffed ravioli and the mozzarella sticks..as well as a slice of the pepperoni pizza! 🍕🍕 all of it had good flavor.. even the marinara sauce which nowadays is often bland.. price was good..! definitely recommend this placedon't let the strip mall that it's in turn u off many stores are for rent.. this place was nice to eat in..🙋🏻‍♂️

I've been in Lake Harmony for a week and this was this most enjoyable meal I've had. My only regret is that it took until my last night to find this restaurant. The place was very busy as I'm sure Friday nights usually are. Our server Tati was very attentive as were the other servers. I highly recommend Papa Santo's and will definitely come back when I'm in the area again.

I love papa Santos pizza but only when the nephew makes it! Sorry this is my opinion as I've purchased pies and I could tell he did not make it! So if he's not there I purchase elsewhere. The buffalo wings are good as well as the shrimp pasta and sausage and peppers sandwich.

Food was not the best outside the pizza. Pizza was pretty good though.

Best pizza and heros in the poco6.

Food is delicious and is priced fair. There is a blond waitress who is absolutely pleasant, polite and excellent at what she does.

I've been there many times. Never disappoints

So good, some of the best Italian I've ever had. Everything we ordered was fantastic. I've been here 3 times and it's always good. Don't let the exterior fool you, it's solid. And BYOB.

Awesome food. Awesome service.

Pizza is great , gravy sauce is sweet with perfect spice.. waitresses are beautiful

Walked in at 9:20pm on a Saturday night. Staff advised us that they were only serving take out pizza... 40 minutes before close. I can’t comment on the quality of their food, but I can say any business that turns away customers 40 minutes before close on a Saturday should make you reconsider.

Love the food here staff is absolutely terrific wait staff is on point constantly checking up on guests making sure everyone is satisfied they do pretty decent take out as well have only ever eaten in but people are constantly popping in taking out.

Visit routinely when up the mountains. Great food and people. Casual atmosphere and good prices. Plenty of parking, easy in and out. Best Pizza in the area!

Tucked in the corner of a tiny strip mall, easy to miss...BUT...pizza is amazing! Friendly, fast service! Now, I just need to know how far they deliver (I'm in Cresco)so I can have this amazingness more often!

Excellent food, huge portions, food service!Badly ended in the area of minimal restarants.

Terrible. The waitress asked how it was and I told her our calzone was COLD in middle and burnt black underneath. She asked if we wanted it back in the oven! No thanks It was hard enough to cut with 3 ppl it's a shame because we were told best place around. $25 for a burnt cold calzone. What's sad is it had could of been great! No discount no nothing and we tipped.

Great food best garlic knots in pocono

Staff were not wearing masks or gloves in defiance of the state health orders. They touched food with bare hands. Extremely mediocre quality to boot. Pickup from elsewhere.

Pizza was delicious!Many varieties including vegan .My husband who is vegan got a veggie pizza.My sister in law got a ham and pineapple with ricotta it was fabulous.

Great food good atmosphere great people a must for people who love to eat out

Food was sloppily prepared chicken sand had 4 tiny pieces of chicken. Felt short changes and staff didn't care gave us a hard time

Great food, great prices and great service. Went there Dec.4th at 6pm.

We planned a visit to Papa Santo's Pizza before our weekend vacation with our kids to Thornton. We were not disappointed! Our waitress was patient & efficient even on a busy Friday night. We dined with our 4 children and everyone enjoyed their dinners. They were extra accomodating to make me a Vegetable Special Pizza without cheese, Very Thankful for that! Our kids loved their Plain Pizza, Cheesesteak stromboli, pasta dishes and mozzarella sticks. Papa Santo's had plenty of menu items to choose from for all of us. To summarize, our youngest asked us mid dinner, "Can we eat here again tomorrow?" Well done Papa Santos, thank you for an enjoyable time & tasty dinner during our Family Winter Vacation!

Very good food choices( pleasant atmosphere) service was great

Surprisingly good, the food is very food, the service is good and the prices excellent. The only thing making it 4 stars instead of 5 is the atmosphere could be improved.

Great pizza and friendly staff and good prices

Waitress was friendly and efficient. Pizza was tasty and priced competitively. Two other pizza shops were closed on a Tuesday, so we went here....it was worth the extra miles...

Always fresh food. Never had any problems. Quality service.

Consistently delicious. Terrific pies and stromboli. Family owned with a crew that works their tail-ends off. Whether you eat in it take out, this place is a legitimate neighborhood pizzeria experience.